Forbidden Love Trope: Writing Romance Against the Rules

They’re not supposed to be together. Society forbids it, families oppose it, laws criminalize it, or circumstances make it impossible. Yet love persists—growing stronger precisely because it’s denied. The forbidden love trope explores romance that defies rules, challenging characters to choose between safety and their hearts.

This guide covers crafting compelling forbidden romances in comics and manga, where barriers create tension and love becomes an act of rebellion.

Understanding Forbidden Love

The trope requires essential elements:

External Prohibition: Something outside the characters prevents their union—not internal doubt or personal choice.

Real Consequences: Breaking the prohibition carries genuine risk.

Love Despite Barriers: Their feelings exist and grow regardless of prohibition.

Central Conflict: The forbidden nature drives the story’s tension.

Why This Trope Resonates

Love as Rebellion

Forbidden love transforms romance into defiance, giving it meaning beyond personal feeling. Choosing love becomes a statement.

Maximum Stakes

When love risks everything, every moment together matters. Small gestures carry enormous weight.

The Thrill of Transgression

Secret meetings, hidden glances, stolen moments—the forbidden adds excitement to ordinary romantic interactions.

Universal Appeal

Everyone has felt the pull toward something they “shouldn’t” want. Forbidden love externalizes that universal experience.

Types of Forbidden Love

Social Class Division

Wealth/status barriers:

• Noble and commoner
• Rich and poor
• Employer and employee
• Different social castes
• Status-conscious families opposing “beneath them” matches

Family Opposition

Specific to these people:

• Feuding families (classic Romeo and Juliet)
• Parent disapproval of specific partner
• Family business rivalry
• Past grievances between families
• Protective family fears

Cultural/Religious Barriers

Larger group divisions:

• Different religions or faiths
• Different cultural backgrounds
• Traditional expectations violated
• Community standards transgressed
• Intergroup conflict manifesting in romance

Power Imbalance Prohibitions

Professional or structural:

• Teacher and student
• Boss and employee
• Mentor and protégé
• Doctor/therapist and patient
• Guard and prisoner

Age Gap Concerns

Generational divide:

• Significant age difference
• “Too young” or “too old” perceptions
• Different life stages
• Social disapproval of gap

Circumstantial Prohibition

Situation-based:

• One or both already committed
• Political alliance requiring different match
• Arranged marriage to someone else
• War making them enemies
• Geographic impossibility

Setting Up the Prohibition

Establish Why It’s Forbidden

Make the barrier concrete:

• What rule or force opposes them?
• Who enforces the prohibition?
• What are the consequences of violation?
• How long has this barrier existed?
• Is it ever transgressed?

Make the Barrier Legitimate

The prohibition should make some sense:

• Show why the rule exists
• Present perspectives supporting the barrier
• Avoid making opposition purely villainous
• Complex situations are more interesting than simple tyranny

Establish the Stakes

What do they risk?

• Social ostracism
• Family disownment
• Career destruction
• Physical danger
• Legal consequences
• Harm to others they care about

Building the Romance

Stage One: Awareness of Attraction

They recognize feelings despite knowing they shouldn’t:

• Noticing each other
• Internal resistance to attraction
• Attempting to dismiss or ignore
• Attraction persisting regardless

Stage Two: Testing Boundaries

Small transgressions begin:

• Conversations that go too long
• Finding excuses to be near each other
• Shared moments that shouldn’t happen
• First acknowledgment (to self) of real feelings

Stage Three: First Major Transgression

The rule is broken:

• First kiss or confession
• A meeting that can’t be explained
• Acknowledging the mutual feeling
• Point of no return for maintaining facade

Stage Four: Secret Relationship

Managing hidden love:

• Developing systems for secret contact
• Close calls and near-discoveries
• Growing resentment of necessary deception
• The relationship deepening despite constraints

Stage Five: Escalating Risk

The secret becomes harder to keep:

• Others beginning to suspect
• Mistakes or slips occurring
• Pressure to formalize “acceptable” relationships
• Growing exhaustion from hiding

Stage Six: Crisis

The secret is exposed or exposure is imminent:

• Confrontation with the prohibition
• Choice point: deny or confirm
• Allies and enemies revealed
• Consequences beginning to fall

Stage Seven: Resolution

The outcome of their choice:

• Together despite everything
• Separated by circumstances
• The world changing to accept them
• Tragedy or triumph

Visual Storytelling

The Barrier Made Visible

Show the prohibition:

• Physical barriers between them (walls, fences, crowds)
• Distance in panel composition
• Observers who force separation
• Environments that highlight difference (their worlds contrasted)

Secret Moments

Visualize hidden intimacy:

• Small panels showing stolen glances
• Private spaces contrasted with public
• Shadows and hidden corners
• The visible tension of restraint in public

Tension and Release

The visual rhythm of forbidden love:

• Constraint in public scenes
• Release in private moments
• The audience/observer presence
• Body language of hiding vs. alone together

Color and Light

Use visual language for emotional states:

• Darkness for secret meetings
• Light for moments of connection
• Contrasting palettes for their different worlds
• Warmth when together, cold when apart

The Discovery Scene

A pivotal moment in forbidden love:

Who Discovers

Options for revelation:

• Antagonist who will use the knowledge
• Ally who will keep the secret
• Authority figure who must respond
• Neutral party whose response is uncertain

The Confrontation

How they’re confronted:

• Public exposure vs. private discovery
• Accusation and denial
• Unable to deny what’s clear
• Choosing to reveal rather than be discovered

The Choice Point

What must they decide:

• Deny everything and end it
• Confirm and face consequences
• Flee together
• Fight to change the prohibition

Common Pitfalls

Trivial Prohibition

If the barrier is easily overcome:

• The “forbidden” feels fake
• No real tension exists
• Resolution is too easy
• Stakes seem manufactured

Make the prohibition genuinely challenging.

Unsympathetic Prohibition

If the barrier is purely unjust:

• No complexity to the conflict
• “Bad guys” opposing for no reason
• Moral simplicity undermines drama
• Better when prohibition has some logic

Problematic Power Dynamics

Some “forbidden” setups are genuinely harmful:

• Adult/minor romanticization
• Predatory power imbalances
• Coerced or impossible consent situations
• Be thoughtful about what “forbidden” you’re portraying

Not all forbidden love is romantic—some is just wrong.

Endless Secrecy

If the secret never develops:

• Story stagnates
• Readers become frustrated
• No forward momentum
• The situation must evolve

Move through stages; don’t stay hidden forever.

Consequence-Free Resolution

If the prohibition just evaporates:

• The story cheated the premise
• Stakes were fake all along
• No meaningful sacrifice occurred
• Resolution feels unearned

Consequences should matter.

Tragic vs. Happy Endings

The Tragedy Option

When they don’t end up together:

• Must feel inevitable, not arbitrary
• The prohibition wins, but love mattered
• Often involves sacrifice
• Catharsis through loss
• The relationship changed something even in ending

The Happy Ending Option

When love triumphs:

• Must be earned, not handed
• Either the world changes or they escape it
• Consequences were faced
• The barrier overcome, not ignored
• Often costs something

The Bittersweet Middle

Partial victory:

• Together but at cost
• Changed circumstances with lingering consequences
• Happy for them, sad for what was lost
• The complexity of real forbidden choices

Variations on the Trope

The Alliance Marriage Complication

Required to marry someone else:

• Political or family arrangement
• Love complicating duty
• Multiple people’s lives affected
• The duty vs. heart conflict

The Secret Identity Barrier

They can’t know who you are:

• Superhero/civilian dynamics
• Undercover operative
• Hidden past preventing honesty
• The relationship built on necessary lies

The Time-Limited Love

Something will force separation:

• Deployment, assignment, sentence
• Terminal illness awareness
• Visa/immigration separation
• Making the most of limited time

The Supernatural Barrier

Non-human complications:

• Vampire and human
• Ghost and living person
• Different species/beings
• Immortal and mortal

Genre Considerations

Historical: Period-appropriate prohibitions (class, race, religion)

Fantasy: Magical barriers, different species, prophecy-based prohibition

Contemporary: Social stigma, professional ethics, family opposition

Sci-Fi: Species differences, political factions, technological barriers

Melodrama: Heightened emotions, dramatic reveals, tragic potential

Supporting Characters

Important roles in forbidden love:

The Enforcer: Person who upholds the prohibition

The Ally: Someone who knows and helps keep the secret

The Threat: Person who suspects and might expose

The Alternative: The “acceptable” option being rejected

The Advisor: Someone who offers perspective on their choice

Creating Your Story with Multic

Forbidden love stories offer natural branching—what risks do they take? How do they respond to near-discovery? What do they sacrifice for each other? Multic’s tools let readers influence how the forbidden romance unfolds, choosing between safety and passion at key moments.

When love is forbidden, choosing it becomes the most powerful statement. Forbidden love stories celebrate the courage to feel what we’re told not to feel, and to pursue what we’re told we cannot have.

---

Related: Enemies to Lovers Trope and Slow Burn Romance Trope