Love Triangle Trope: Writing Compelling Three-Way Romantic Tension

Two people love one. Or one person loves two. The love triangle trope creates romantic tension through impossible choices—forcing characters (and readers) to consider what they truly want, what love means, and what they’re willing to sacrifice.

This guide explores crafting compelling love triangles in comics and manga that satisfy rather than frustrate, with fully developed characters and meaningful stakes.

Understanding Love Triangles

The classic structure involves:

The Chooser: Person who must decide between two romantic options.

Option A: First potential partner with distinct appeal.

Option B: Second potential partner with different appeal.

The conflict: Both options are valid. The choice is genuinely difficult.

Why This Trope Works (And Fails)

When It Works

• Each option represents something meaningful
• The chooser has understandable reasons to be torn
• All three characters are fully developed
• The choice reveals character, not just preference
• The resolution feels earned

When It Fails

• One option is obviously “right”
• A character exists only to create obstacles
• The chooser strings people along indefinitely
• The resolution feels arbitrary
• Character development stops for triangle drama

Types of Love Triangles

The Classic (A loves B, C loves B)

B must choose between A and C:

• Most common structure
• B is the chooser
• A and C may be rivals or strangers
• Focus on B’s decision process

The Chain (A loves B, B loves C)

Unrequited line of desire:

• More tragic structure
• No clean resolution possible
• Explores unrequited love
• Often one connection is blocked

The Complete Triangle (All love each other)

Polyamorous potential:

• Rare but increasingly explored
• All three have genuine feelings
• Opens possibility of resolution as triad
• Challenges traditional romance structure

The Rivalry Triangle (A and B want C, A and B also rivals)

Competition adds dimension:

• The rivals’ relationship matters
• C is often passive in choosing
• A vs. B conflict parallels romance
• Resolution affects rivalry too

Setting Up Your Triangle

Make All Characters Compelling

Critical: No one should be obviously wrong.

For Each Corner:

• Distinct personality and appeal
• Valid reasons someone would love them
• Individual goals beyond the romance
• Understandable perspective on the situation
• Growth arc within the story

Define What Each Represents

The two options should offer different things:

Safety vs. Passion: Comfortable love vs. intense attraction

Past vs. Future: History and comfort vs. new possibility

Head vs. Heart: Logical choice vs. emotional pull

Similar vs. Different: Someone like them vs. someone who challenges them

Stability vs. Adventure: Secure life vs. uncertain excitement

Establish Why Choosing Is Hard

If the choice is easy, there’s no story:

• Both options genuinely appeal
• History complicates things
• External factors pressure both directions
• The chooser’s values conflict
• What they want vs. what they need

Building Triangle Tension

Stage One: Establishment

Introduce the dynamic:

• Show appeal of first connection
• Introduce second option compellingly
• Create scenario where both are present
• Establish stakes for choosing

Stage Two: Developing Both Connections

Give both options genuine screen time:

• Meaningful moments with each
• Reasons for connection becoming clear
• Readers able to see appeal of both
• Neither option neglected narratively

Stage Three: Complications

The triangle tightens:

• Direct comparison situations
• Jealousy moments (handled carefully)
• External pressure to choose
• Near-decisions that reverse
• Others noticing and commenting

Stage Four: Internal Conflict

The chooser’s struggle deepens:

• What do they actually want?
• What are they afraid of?
• What do the options represent about their life?
• Self-knowledge emerging from the choice

Stage Five: Crisis

A decision becomes necessary:

• Can’t maintain status quo
• One option forcing the issue
• External event demanding choice
• The chooser reaching clarity

Stage Six: Resolution

The choice and aftermath:

• Decision made and explained
• Chosen option’s response
• Unchosen option’s response
• Consequences playing out
• New status quo establishing

The Unchosen Option

How you handle the “loser” matters enormously:

Don’t Villainize Them

The temptation to make the unchosen person “wrong”:

• Don’t reveal hidden flaws to justify the choice
• Don’t have them react in ugly ways
• Don’t minimize their feelings
• Don’t pretend they’ll be immediately fine

Give Them Dignity

They were worthy of love:

• Let them have a graceful response
• Show the sadness without melodrama
• Allow them their own story going forward
• Don’t reduce them to the rejection

Consider Their Future

Options for the unchosen:

• Their own romance (carefully timed)
• Growth and moving on
• Changed relationship with the others
• Their own goals and life

Visual Storytelling Techniques

Panel Positioning

Show dynamics through layout:

• Triangle compositions in group scenes
• The chooser positioned between options
• Distance representing emotional closeness
• Paired vs. third-wheeled arrangements

Color and Visual Association

Give each connection distinct feeling:

• Color schemes associated with each option
• Lighting differences in scenes with each
• Visual motifs for each relationship
• Contrast when toggling between connections

Body Language

Physical dynamics reveal truth:

• Who the chooser gravitates toward unconsciously
• Eye contact patterns in group scenes
• Tension in bodies when all three present
• Comfort vs. electricity in different pairs

Parallel Scenes

Compare moments with each option:

• Similar situations, different dynamics
• Same location, different person
• Mirrored confessions or conversations
• Before/after with each

Common Pitfalls

The Obvious Choice

If one option is clearly better:

• The struggle feels fake
• Readers lose patience with the chooser
• The unchosen person seems pathetic
• The resolution is unsatisfying

Make both options genuinely appealing.

The Passive Chooser

If the chooser doesn’t actually choose:

• They seem cruel or cowardly
• External factors making the decision frustrates
• An unchosen option leaving isn’t satisfying
• The romantic arc has no agency

The chooser must actively decide.

The Forgotten Third

When one option disappears:

• The triangle stops being a triangle
• The story breaks its promise
• Readers invested in that option feel cheated
• The choice becomes no choice

Keep all three present and relevant.

Endless Dithering

If the triangle lasts too long:

• Readers lose patience
• The chooser seems unable to commit
• Drama for drama’s sake
• No forward momentum

The triangle must progress and resolve.

Character Assassination

Making an option “bad” to resolve:

• Feels like cheating
• Wastes character development
• Insults reader investment
• Suggests the choice didn’t matter

Resolve through preference, not revelation of flaws.

Alternative Resolutions

The Chooser Chooses Themselves

Neither option is right:

• Valid if built toward
• Not a cop-out if earned
• Shows self-awareness
• Must feel conclusive

The Triad

All three together:

• Requires careful groundwork
• Addresses why choosing is hard
• Not traditional but increasingly valid
• Needs genuine exploration

The Mutual Release

Both options step back:

• Can feel noble or frustrating
• Works if the chooser’s struggle was the point
• Gives agency to the options
• Often a transitional moment

The Long Game

One now, reconsidered later:

• More realistic for some scenarios
• Must handle carefully to not diminish first choice
• Works in series with time skips
• Requires both options to still be viable

Triangle Variations

Best Friend’s Love Interest

Pre-existing loyalty complicates:

• Friendship vs. romance conflict
• Guilt adding to attraction
• Betrayal stakes
• More fraught resolution

The New Person Threat

Established couple + newcomer:

• Tests existing relationship
• Newcomer often catalyst for issues already present
• Couple may strengthen through threat
• Or reveal fundamental problems

The Return

Ex returns to complicate current relationship:

• History vs. present
• Second chance romance elements
• Current partner feeling threatened
• The past’s pull vs. current reality

The Oblivious Corner

One person unaware they’re in a triangle:

• Dramatic irony
• The reveal is major moment
• Often the chooser is oblivious to their own options
• Comedy or drama depending on handling

Reader Investment

Triangles create “teams”:

Handling Reader Preference

• Don’t mock readers who prefer the unchosen
• Build genuine cases for both
• Let the resolution make sense regardless of reader preference
• Acknowledge that reasonable people could choose differently

Avoiding Frustration

• Keep the choice moving forward
• Show why the chooser is genuinely torn
• Don’t repeat the same conflicts
• Resolution should feel conclusive

Creating Your Story with Multic

Love triangles are perfect for branching narratives—let readers influence who the chooser spends time with, how they respond to moments with each option. Multic’s tools allow for parallel path exploration, where different choices lead to different relationships, giving readers agency in the romantic outcome.

A well-crafted love triangle isn’t about who wins—it’s about understanding why the choice is hard, what it reveals about the characters, and the bittersweet truth that some genuine love must remain unfulfilled.

---

Related: Rivals to Lovers Trope and Romance Webtoon Guide