Don't have time to read? Jump straight in to creating! Try Multic Free

January 21, 2025 11 min read

How to Make a Horror Visual Novel: Craft Interactive Terror

Learn to create horror visual novels with genuine scares, psychological tension, and branching nightmares. Master the art of interactive fear.

Horror visual novels face a unique challenge: you’re trying to scare players who control the pace of reading. They can pause. They can close the game. Yet the best horror VNs manage to create dread so compelling that players keep clicking despite wanting to stop.

Why Horror Works in Visual Novels

The format offers distinct advantages for fear:

Complicity: In a horror movie, you watch characters make bad decisions. In a horror VN, you make those decisions. You chose to open that door. That makes the consequences personal.

Pacing Control: You control reading speed—but so does the game. Timed text, sudden reveals, forced pauses create horror’s essential rhythm of tension and release.

Investment Before Terror: VNs excel at character development. When players have spent hours with characters, those characters’ suffering lands harder.

Multiple Fates: Different choices can lead to different horrible outcomes. The question shifts from “will they survive?” to “which nightmare will this choice create?”

Horror Subgenres for Visual Novels

Psychological Horror

Focus: Mind, perception, sanity Threats: Reality distortion, paranoia, mental deterioration Best For: VNs—dialogue-heavy format suits internal horror

Key Elements:

Unreliable narrator (the player character)
Reality shifts (what was true may not be)
Slow-building dread
Few or subtle visual scares
Questions without answers

Survival Horror

Focus: Resource scarcity, pursuit, escape Threats: Physical danger, monsters, killers Best For: Hybrid VN/gameplay or choice-heavy survival

Key Elements:

Clear threat pursuing characters
Choices about resource use
Character death from wrong choices
Tension between safety and goals
Escape or victory possible

Cosmic Horror

Focus: Insignificance, unknowable forces Threats: Entities beyond comprehension Best For: Narrative VNs exploring existential dread

Key Elements:

Vast, inhuman forces
Knowledge itself as danger
Protagonists cannot “win” traditionally
Endings range from bad to worse
Atmosphere over action

Body Horror

Focus: Physical transformation, violation of bodily autonomy Threats: Disease, mutation, corruption Best For: Visual medium allows body horror imagery

Key Elements:

Visual emphasis on transformation
Loss of control over one’s body
Disgust combined with fascination
Often metaphorical (addiction, illness, etc.)
Character-driven stakes

Supernatural Horror

Focus: Ghosts, curses, otherworldly threats Threats: The dead, demons, cursed objects Best For: Mystery-investigation VN structure

Key Elements:

Rules-based supernatural system
Investigation into cause
Often features past events affecting present
Multiple possible explanations
Resolution possible through understanding

Mechanics of Fear

Building Dread

Terror is short; dread lingers. Prioritize dread:

The Dread Formula:

Establish normalcy
Introduce wrongness (small, missable)
Wrongness grows (undeniable)
Tension peaks
Release (scare or false alarm)
New normal is worse
Repeat with escalation

Wrongness Techniques:

Something moved in the background
Character says something slightly off
Environment detail changed between scenes
Sound that doesn’t match anything visible
Contradiction player might notice

Timing and Pacing

Control the rhythm of fear:

Text Speed Manipulation:

Slow text for dread building
Normal speed for calm sections
Fast text for panic
Sudden stops for impact

Silence and Sound:

Ambient sound during calm
Sound cuts (silence is unsettling)
Sudden sound breaks silence
Wrong sounds for situations

Visual Timing:

Character sprite changes
Background alterations
Flash frames (single-frame scares)
Darkness before reveals

Choice as Horror Mechanism

Every choice in horror VNs carries weight:

Choice Horror Types:

Lose-Lose: Both options lead to bad outcomes. Player must choose which horror.

The creature is coming. You can only save one.
> Save the child → Adult character dies
> Save the adult → Child character dies

False Safety: Choice seems safe but isn’t.

> Hide in the closet
[Character hides, feels safe, begins to relax]
[Something is already in the closet]

Complicity: Player must do something horrible to proceed.

The ritual requires a sacrifice. Your companion volunteers.
> Accept their sacrifice → Story continues, guilt follows
> Refuse → Both die, bad ending

Knowledge vs. Safety: Learn more but increase danger.

> Read the diary → Learn crucial information, but now IT knows you know
> Leave it → Safer but miss important context

Writing Horror Content

The First Hour

Horror VNs need careful openings:

Opening Structure:

Establish protagonist (who are we?)
Establish normalcy (what’s life like?)
Establish relationships (who do we care about?)
First wrongness (something’s not right)
First hook (we need to know more)

Common Opening Patterns:

New Location: Character arrives somewhere unfamiliar. Perfect for gradual wrongness discovery.

Return: Character returns to childhood home, abandoned place. Past and present horror connect.

After the Incident: Story starts after something happened. Player pieces together what while facing consequences.

Normal Day Gone Wrong: Ordinary day interrupted by horror. Relatability makes horror more affecting.

Dialogue in Horror

Characters shouldn’t announce the horror—they should react like people:

Horror Dialogue Patterns:

Denial:

"It was just the wind."
"Old houses make noise. It doesn't mean anything."
"I must have left it like that."

Rationalization:

"There has to be an explanation."
"Maybe I'm just tired."
"My mind's playing tricks on me."

Growing Acceptance:

"I don't think we're alone here."
"Something's wrong. Really wrong."
"We need to leave. Now."

Breaking Point:

"It's real. It's all real."
"We're not going to make it."
"I can hear it. I can hear it breathing."

Show vs. Tell in Horror

What you don’t show is often scarier:

Effective Horror Description:

NOT: "A terrifying monster appeared."

BETTER: "Something filled the doorway. She saw a shape—wrong
proportions, too many joints—before her flashlight died."

BEST: "The flashlight flickered. In the strobing light, she
saw something move toward her, and her brain simply refused
to process what it was."

The Reader’s Imagination: Give enough detail to terrify, but leave gaps for imagination. What readers create in those gaps is worse than what you could describe.

Character Death

In horror, characters can die. Handle it with intention:

Death That Works:

Established characters we care about
Deaths that result from choices (or feel like they could have been prevented)
Deaths that mean something narratively
Deaths that increase stakes for survivors

Death That Fails:

Random character dies for shock value
Death has no impact on story or survivors
Death feels unavoidable regardless of choice
Death of characters we never connected with

Survivor Guilt: After deaths, surviving characters (and players) should feel it:

Dialogue acknowledges the loss
Choices about how to process
The dead character’s absence felt
Questions about whether it could have been different

Visual Design for Horror

Atmosphere Through Art

Visual design creates horror atmosphere:

Color and Lighting:

Desaturated palettes suggest wrongness
Contrast between light and dark
Color symbolism (red as danger, sickly greens)
Light sources within scenes create pools of safety and danger

Environmental Design:

Liminal spaces (hallways, empty rooms, transitions)
Wrongness in ordinary settings
Signs of previous presence
Decay and age

Character Sprites for Horror

Horror sprites need specific considerations:

Essential Horror Expressions:

Fear (gradations from uneasy to terrified)
Shock/frozen
Pain/injury states
Corrupted/wrong versions (if applicable)
Dead/near-death states

Transformation: If characters change (corruption, possession, injury):

Gradual state changes
Uncanny valley effects
Sprite variations showing progression

The Monster Question

How to show (or not show) threats:

Showing Monsters:

Detailed monster art is less scary than implied monsters
If shown: show in glimpses first
Full reveals should be earned
Art style affects horror (realistic vs. stylized)

Not Showing:

Silhouettes
Aftermath of monster’s presence
Character reactions tell us what they see
Sound design fills visual gap

Hybrid Approach:

Partial reveals that grow over time
Distorted views (corrupted visual effects)
Multiple possible appearances (what is it really?)

CG Placement for Horror

Where to use special illustrations:

High-Impact Horror CG Moments:

First major scare/reveal
Character death scenes
Key transformation moments
Ending variations

CG Style for Horror:

Match or contrast regular art style
Detail where it serves horror
Composition guides fear (what’s in shadows, edges)

Branching Horror

Route Design

Horror routes often follow survival logic:

Route Types:

Investigation Routes: Different approaches to understanding the threat.

> Research the history → Uncover supernatural origin
> Follow the patterns → Uncover human cause
> Trust the visions → Uncover cosmic truth

Survival Routes: Different strategies for staying alive.

> Fight → Some survive through violence
> Hide → Some survive through caution
> Escape → Some escape but leave others behind

Character Routes: Relationships determine who survives and how.

> Trust Alex → Alex survives, different ending path
> Trust Sam → Sam survives, different ending path

Ending Variety

Horror endings rarely have “happy” options:

Horror Ending Types:

Survived: Characters escape, but at cost. Horror contained, not resolved.

Pyrrhic Victory: Threat defeated, but what was sacrificed? Worth it?

Bad End: Characters don’t survive. Specific to choices made.

True End: Full understanding of horror. Often worst emotionally—knowing is worse.

Secret End: Hidden ending requiring specific path. Sometimes offers hope, sometimes deepest horror.

Ending Distribution: Not all playthroughs should feel identical:

First playthrough often gets survival ending
Deeper engagement reveals worse truths
No ending should feel “complete”—horror lingers

Choice Consequences

Horror consequences should feel inevitable in hindsight:

The Horror Butterfly Effect: Small early choices → large consequences later

Act 1: Keep the strange pendant?
> Yes → [Acts 2-3: You're marked, it can find you]
> No → [Acts 2-3: Different danger, but different tools]

Visible vs. Hidden Consequences:

Some consequences immediate (this room is now dangerous)
Some consequences delayed (that choice saves you in Act 3)
Some consequences hidden (you’ll never know what you avoided)

Common Mistakes

Jump Scares as Foundation

Jump scares alone aren’t horror—they’re startles. They work once.

Fix: Build dread, use jump scares sparingly as punctuation, not structure.

Excessive Gore

Gore isn’t automatically scary. Constant gore becomes numbing.

Fix: Use gore deliberately. Less is more. Implication often more affecting than explicit content.

Omniscient Horror

If the threat is all-powerful and all-knowing, choices feel meaningless.

Fix: Threats should have rules, limitations, and blind spots that choices can exploit.

Unsympathetic Victims

If readers don’t care about characters, their suffering doesn’t land.

Fix: Develop characters before endangering them. Give them enough depth to mourn.

Inconsistent Tone

Mixing horror with inappropriate comedy or drama undercuts fear.

Fix: Deliberate tonal management. Relief moments serve tension—they don’t break it.

Getting Started

Your horror VN action plan:

Choose your horror type
- What kind of fear?
- What’s the central threat?
- What tone are you aiming for?
Design the threat
- What is it?
- What are its rules?
- How can characters interact with it?
- What don’t they (and we) understand?
Plan character development before danger
- Who are these people?
- Why do we care about them?
- What makes their survival/death meaningful?
Map the fear arc
- How does dread build?
- Where are the peaks?
- How do choices affect the arc?
Design consequences
- What choices lead where?
- What are the endings?
- How do different paths create different fears?

For collaborative horror projects—where maintaining tone across branches is crucial—Multic offers tools for teams to coordinate complex narratives. The visual node system helps track how choices branch through different nightmare scenarios while maintaining consistent dread.

The darkness is waiting. What horrors will you create?