Underdog Story Trope: Writing Against-All-Odds Narratives

They shouldn’t win. Every metric says they’ll lose. The odds are stacked, the opposition overwhelming, the situation impossible. But somehow, against everything, they find a way. The underdog story speaks to our deepest hopes about determination, heart, and the possibility of triumph.

This guide explores how to write underdog narratives that inspire and satisfy.

Why Underdogs Resonate

Universal Identification

Most people feel like underdogs sometimes:

• Facing challenges that seem too big
• Competing against superior opponents
• Starting from disadvantaged positions
• Doubting their own capabilities

We root for underdogs because we see ourselves in them.

The Promise of Hope

Underdog stories say effort matters:

• Hard work can overcome talent gaps
• Determination beats resources
• Heart trumps advantages
• Anyone can succeed

Emotional Investment

Underdogs earn our support:

• Their struggles make victories meaningful
• We feel their setbacks personally
• Their wins become our wins
• The journey matters as much as the outcome

Satisfying Justice

Something feels right when underdogs win:

• The arrogant are humbled
• The dismissed prove their worth
• Fairness triumphs over circumstance
• Merit defeats privilege

Types of Underdog Disadvantages

Skill Gap

They’re simply less capable:

• Less training or experience
• Natural talent differences
• Knowledge disparities
• Technical inferiority

Story Need: Show them closing the gap through effort, strategy, or discovery.

Resource Disadvantage

They lack what opponents have:

• Money and equipment
• Team size or support
• Information and intelligence
• Institutional backing

Story Need: Demonstrate resourcefulness and creative problem-solving.

Physical Disadvantage

Their bodies work against them:

• Size or strength differences
• Disabilities or conditions
• Age (too young or old)
• Physical damage or limitation

Story Need: Show how they compensate or transcend limitations.

Social Disadvantage

Society stacks against them:

• Class or background discrimination
• Institutional barriers
• Reputation damage
• Lack of connections or support

Story Need: Navigate or overcome systemic obstacles.

Psychological Disadvantage

Internal struggles holding them back:

• Trauma or fear
• Self-doubt
• Past failures haunting them
• Psychological barriers

Story Need: Personal growth enabling performance.

Building the Disadvantage

Make It Real

The disadvantage must be genuine:

• Not easily overcome
• Visible to readers
• Acknowledged by other characters
• Creating actual consequences

Make It Specific

Vague disadvantage lacks impact:

• “They’re weaker” vs. “They can’t throw hard enough to compete”
• “They’re poor” vs. “They can’t afford the entry fee”
• Concrete limitations create concrete challenges

Make It Sympathetic

We should care about their struggle:

• The disadvantage isn’t their fault
• They’re handling it with dignity
• Their response shows character
• Overcoming it would be meaningful

Make It Relevant

The disadvantage must matter to the goal:

• Directly impacts their ability to succeed
• Creates specific obstacles to overcome
• Shapes the strategies they must use
• Defines what victory requires

The Opponent: The Favorite

Establishing Superiority

Make the opponent legitimately formidable:

• Show their victories
• Demonstrate their abilities
• Establish their reputation
• Display their resources

Avoiding Caricature

Even opponents need dimension:

• Why are they successful?
• What drives them?
• Do they have sympathetic qualities?
• Are they aware of their advantages?

The Attitude Spectrum

Opponents can range from:

Dismissive: Don’t take the underdog seriously Respectful: Acknowledge the challenge despite advantages Threatened: Sense the underdog might win Conflicted: Question whether their victory would be meaningful

Earned Defeat

When the favorite loses:

• It should feel possible given what we’ve seen
• Their weakness should have been established
• The underdog’s strategy should have been foreshadowed
• The loss should affect them meaningfully

Earning the Victory

The Training Montage

Show the work:

• Visible effort toward improvement
• Specific skill development
• Setbacks and perseverance
• Measurable progress

The Hidden Advantage

Something the underdog has that matters:

• Unconventional technique
• Unique perspective
• Superior determination
• Special knowledge or ability

This shouldn’t negate the disadvantage—it should provide a path despite it.

The Moment of Crisis

When defeat seems certain:

• Everything has failed
• The disadvantage seems insurmountable
• Hope appears lost
• Something must change

The Breakthrough

What enables victory:

• Application of learned skills
• Revelation of hidden strength
• Support from allies
• Transcending limitations

The Victory Itself

Should feel earned:

• Close rather than dominant
• Cost something
• Surprise those who doubted
• Change the underdog’s position

Visual Techniques

Size and Composition

Show the disparity:

• Small underdog against large opponent
• Few against many
• Poor equipment against superior
• Isolation against support

The Comeback Sequence

Visualize the turn:

• Darkest moment compositions
• Shift in energy and movement
• Growing momentum
• Triumphant final panels

Audience Reaction

Show others responding:

• Initial dismissal or pity
• Growing attention
• Shocked recognition
• Celebration of victory

Physical Transformation

Show the effort’s cost:

• Exhaustion and strain
• Injuries accumulated
• Determination in expression
• Body pushed to limits

Common Pitfalls

The False Underdog

If their “disadvantage” is trivial or easily overcome, they’re not really an underdog. The struggle must be genuine.

Hidden Superiority

“The underdog was actually the most talented all along” negates the entire story. Hidden potential is fine; secret superiority isn’t.

Unearned Victory

Winning through luck, opponent error, or deus ex machina cheats readers. The underdog must cause their victory.

Effortless Comeback

If overcoming the disadvantage seems easy, it wasn’t real. Show the cost and difficulty.

Forgotten Disadvantage

The limitation that defined them shouldn’t disappear. Either they compensate for it or they struggle with it throughout.

Opponent Stupidity

The favorite losing because they made obvious mistakes isn’t satisfying. They should perform well and still lose.

Subverting the Underdog Story

The Underdog Loses

Sometimes effort isn’t enough. Exploring what happens after failure with dignity.

The Favorite’s Perspective

Tell the story from the expected winner’s viewpoint. Are they really the villain?

The False Narrative

The “underdog” has been hiding advantages. Questions about perception and narrative manipulation.

The Pyrrhic Victory

The underdog wins but at too great a cost. Was it worth it?

The System Wins

Individual underdog triumph doesn’t change structural injustice. Examining limits of personal victory.

Types of Underdog Stories

Sports Underdog

The classic format:

• Clear competition
• Measurable disadvantage
• Training progression
• Climactic match

Professional Underdog

Competing in career contexts:

• Business competition
• Artistic rivalry
• Academic challenges
• Professional advancement

Social Underdog

Fighting for recognition:

• Against discrimination
• For acceptance
• To change perception
• For equal treatment

Combat Underdog

Physical conflict against superior foes:

• Overpowered enemies
• Outnumbered situations
• Outgunned confrontations
• David versus Goliath

Building Emotional Investment

Early Sympathy

Make readers care before the challenge:

• Establish likeable qualities
• Show them facing unfairness
• Create personal stakes
• Reveal their dreams

Increasing Stakes

What they stand to gain and lose:

• Personal meaning of victory
• Consequences of failure
• What others depend on them for
• How their identity relates to the challenge

Supporter Characters

People who believe in them:

• The mentor who sees potential
• The friend who never doubts
• The former opponent who respects them
• The community rooting for them

The Naysayers

People who dismiss them:

• The expert who predicts failure
• The institution that excludes them
• The rival who mocks them
• The system that’s stacked against them

Creating Your Underdog Story

Multic’s collaborative features let teams develop different aspects—one creator building the underdog’s struggles while another develops the favorite’s perspective—creating richer narratives through combined effort.

The underdog story remains one of fiction’s most beloved forms. Execute it authentically, and readers will cheer every hard-won inch of progress.

---

Related: Tournament Arc Guide and Training Arc Trope